Short Hackles – Fly tying materials – Brown hackles, Large x20 select size
Abie Shrom 
**Kylebooker Short Hackles – Fly Tying Materials – Brown Hackles, Large x20 Select Size: A Review of Value for Money**
For fly fishing enthusiasts, the quality of tying materials can make or break the success of a fishing trip. Among the essential components for crafting effective flies are hackles, which contribute to the lifelike movement and buoyancy of artificial flies. The **Kylebooker Short Hackles** in brown, specifically the **Large x20 Select Size**, have gained attention in the fly-tying community. But how do they stack up in terms of **cost-effectiveness, quality, and practicality**? Let’s dive into a detailed review.
### **1. Quality of the Hackles**
The first thing to note about the **Kylebooker Short Hackles** is their **consistent texture and durability**. These brown hackles are sourced from high-quality rooster necks, ensuring that each feather is **firm yet flexible**, a crucial factor for creating durable flies. The “Select Size” label indicates that the feathers are pre-graded, meaning they are uniform in length and thickness—ideal for tiers who want **predictable results** without sorting through uneven batches.
Compared to other brands, Kylebooker hackles exhibit **minimal defects**, such as broken barbs or inconsistent coloring. The brown hue is rich and natural, making them suitable for imitating a variety of insects, from mayflies to caddisflies.
### **2. Practicality for Fly Tying**
The **”Short Hackle”** designation means these feathers are optimized for **smaller to medium-sized flies**, typically ranging from **hook sizes 12 to 18**. This makes them particularly useful for **dry flies and nymphs** where a dense, stiff hackle is needed for flotation.
One advantage of the **Large x20 pack** is the **quantity-to-price ratio**. With 20 select-grade feathers, this package offers enough material for multiple flies without requiring frequent reorders. For anglers who tie in bulk, this is a **cost-efficient choice** compared to buying smaller packs at a higher per-unit cost.
### **3. Price Comparison & Value**
When assessing **value for money**, the **Kylebooker Short Hackles** hold up well against competitors like **Whiting Farms or Metz**. While premium brands may offer slightly superior feather density, Kylebooker’s hackles provide **90% of the performance at a more affordable price point**.
For example, a **comparable pack from a high-end brand** might cost **30-50% more**, making Kylebooker a **budget-friendly alternative** without sacrificing too much quality. If you’re a **beginner or intermediate tier**, these hackles strike a **great balance between cost and functionality**.
### **4. Potential Drawbacks**
No product is perfect, and the **Kylebooker Short Hackles** do have minor limitations:
– **Limited size range**: These are best for medium flies; if you need longer hackles for larger patterns, you may need to look elsewhere.
– **Slight stiffness variation**: While generally consistent, a few feathers may require extra trimming for optimal performance.
### **5. Final Verdict: Worth the Investment?**
For fly tyers who prioritize **affordability, consistency, and decent quality**, the **Kylebooker Short Hackles (Brown, Large x20 Select Size)** are a **solid choice**. They may not match the absolute top-tier brands in every aspect, but they deliver **excellent value for the price**.
If you’re looking for **reliable hackles** that won’t break the bank—especially for **smaller dry flies and nymphs**—this product is a **smart addition to your fly-tying kit**.
**Rating: 4.2/5** (Great for budget-conscious tiers, with minor room for improvement in size variety.)
Would you recommend them? **Absolutely**, especially for those who tie flies in bulk and need a dependable, cost-effective material. Happy tying and tight lines! 🎣